there should be a sticky'd poll for this question broken out by weight class
i'll weigh in again though. i'm 5'11 and ~200lb. once seated they are pretty snug. not a deal breaker but i'd say right on the precipice of being intolerable. The biggest problem is the thigh bolster height; they are ridiculously tall and unless you get in *just so* then there's going to be major wear on the leather on the bolsters way faster than the rest of the seat. My leg barely fits between the bottom of the wheel and the bolster. There's no way my gf would be able to get in and out with a torn miniscus
If BMW had implemented a comfort-type entry (a la Lexus) where the seat automatically slides back when the vehicle shuts off then I think I might have considered them. Hopefully they'll shave an inch or two off the thigh bolsters next gen